Fair Value
Fair Value is the value of the machinery on the assumption that the factory continues as a going concern — each machine valued as operational in its current installed position (in-situ), contributing to the factory’s production capacity.
When a manufacturing company enters the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code’s Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP), the Resolution Professional (RP) immediately commences the asset listing and valuation process.
The factory’s plant and machinery is among the primary assets that the RP must value and include in the Information Memorandum (IM) for potential Resolution Applicants.
Understanding what Fair Value and Liquidation Value mean for your factory’s equipment, and how the IBBI-appointed P&M Registered Valuer’s certificate affects the resolution plan, is critical for both the RP and for the company’s management.
The CIRP valuation distinguishes between machinery operating as part of a going concern and machinery considered for individual sale.
Within the first 75 days of CIRP, the Resolution Professional appoints two independent IBBI Registered Valuers in the P&M asset class to independently determine Fair Value and Liquidation Value.
A2Z Valuers holds the IBBI P&M Registered Valuer credential. The RP commissions the two valuers simultaneously; their independent certificates are averaged to produce the final values used in the Information Memorandum (IM).
The same factory machinery can carry different values depending on whether the factory continues as a going concern or the equipment is considered for individual sale.
Fair Value is the value of the machinery on the assumption that the factory continues as a going concern — each machine valued as operational in its current installed position (in-situ), contributing to the factory’s production capacity.
Liquidation Value is the value of the machinery if the factory is shut down and each piece of equipment is removed, transported and sold individually on the secondary market (ex-situ).
For specialised equipment, the gap between Fair Value and Liquidation Value is wider.
If the Fair Value of the factory’s P&M is ₹12 crore and the Liquidation Value is ₹7.5 crore, the CoC will not accept a resolution plan that offers them less than ₹7.5 crore from the P&M component.
A Resolution Applicant who plans to acquire the factory as a going concern will base their bid on a value between the Fair Value and the Liquidation Value — the machinery’s contribution to the business’s enterprise value.
A well-maintained factory with documented equipment condition and maintenance history typically produces a higher Fair Value — and a higher Liquidation Value — than a factory with deferred maintenance and undocumented equipment history.
Documented machinery condition supports the valuation assessment.
Maintenance records provide evidence of the equipment’s history and upkeep.
Undocumented equipment history can affect the resulting valuation assessment.
Whether you are dealing with CIRP, resolution planning or factory asset valuation, discuss your P&M valuation requirement with A2Z Valuers.